If you take video proof there should be no gripes, in the end, hard evidence is the best route. Also, do you have any idea how much of a headache it is to dig up such specific logs? If everyone asked to pull them up the admins would certainly do a backflip off a highrise building, while cursing the firstborn child of all Asylum players.
EDIT: all of them, hand in hand. It would be like one of those freeze-frame moments from a cheesy sitcom, except more death....and cat memes for commemoration.